Max Scherzer, Aaron Judge among MLB’s over-hated, overrated

Max Scherzer, Aaron Judge among MLB's over-hated, overrated

Welcome to the 15th edition of Overrated and Over-hated! 

The mission here, as always, is less to offer thumbs-up or thumbs-down verdicts on people, actions and ideas in the baseball world (and a few non-baseball issues) and more to push back at established narratives. To encourage a collective calming down, if you will. An overrated player might be perfectly good, just not as as advertised. And vice versa for the over-hated.

Happy and healthy and new year to all. Same time next Overrated and Over-hated?

Greg Allen: Overrated.