I wore a celeb-approved scarf top — & survived the catcalls


Sometimes you have to go all-in — even if you’re falling out.

That’s what I told myself as I prepared to test out the biggest celebrity trend of summer 2021: the barely there crossed scarf top. A-listers Kylie Jenner, Bella Hadid and Emily Ratajkowski are all fans of the early aughts throwback style popularized by Christina Aguilera in her 2002 “Dirrty” prime.

But can an average, size 8, 22-year-old pull it off?

After scouring Google for options, I settled on a black and gold print Mystique NYC top for $22, that was honestly more like a slippery bikini top than a shirt. (While you could try to loop a scarf or sarong to get the look, it’s easier to buy one pre-tied and designed to be worn this way.)

As I strapped it on, I felt some insecurity bubble up. I’m pretty confident, but I’m also no spray-tanned, perfectly toned supermodel. The “shirt” — if you can call it that — exposed every lump, bump and mark that I’m usually so quick to cover up.

Brooke Kato
Features reporter Brooke Kato attempted a celeb favorite scarf top on the streets of NYC.
Stefano Giovannini

My best friend and I had an action-packed day planned, starting with a trip on the LIRR into Manhattan. The first time a train hit a bump, I knew I was asking for trouble. This top was a nip-slip waiting to happen. Thank God for my fast reflexes and a nearly empty train car.

The brazen inspiration: Christina Aguilera rocked the scarf top on the red carpet at the 2002 VMAS.
The brazen inspiration: Christina Aguilera rocked the scarf top on the red carpet at the 2002 VMAS.
PA Images via Getty Images

Forty minutes later, we were outside Penn Station. I felt the wall of tourists, businessmen and buskers fix their eyes on me as I bared it all in the beating sun.

At 11 a.m., it felt too early to be wearing something so skimpy. Still, I pretended not to notice all the eyes glued to my sternum tattoo: a cherry red butterfly that doesn’t typically see the light of day, especially without a beach nearby. I ignored the catcalls from construction workers and the snide comments from men sitting on curbs, snaking my way around ones who tried to approach me.

“Your shirt,” was all one down-and-out-looking guy had to say, as he held both his hands up mere inches from my chest.

The sweat started dripping out of every pore in my body. Was it the 90-degree heat, the polyester blend or a panic attack?

Pro tip: silky scarf tops and sweat do not mix. For the next few hours, stopping to adjust my shirt became a regular occurrence.

Bella Hadid and Kylie Jenner recently both sported the scarf top on the beach.
Bella Hadid and Kylie Jenner both sported the scarf top on the beach recently.
The Mega Agency; kyliejenner/Instagram

A handful of indecent exposures later — and getting caught in thunderstorms that showered off my sweat — we found ourselves in Dumbo, and snagged some eats from Time Out Market.

That’s when things turned around.

We joined the hordes of Brooklyn-goers sheltering from the rain, and I discovered that, despite my stomach rolls — along with everything else — being on display, the tiny top started getting the right kind of attention, earning me compliments from tourists, New Yorkers and food workers alike.

“Your shirt is so cute,” one girl offered.

“I like your tattoo,” another enthusiastically shouted as she prepared food. “I want to get one just like it!”

Brooke Kato
Brooke grabbed a bite to eat at the Mean Fiddler’s bottomless brunch to prepare for her all-day outing.
Stefano Giovannini

Forget men — I can always count on women to boost my confidence, making me feel like a supermodel despite my rain-soaked bangs and dripping jeans.

Ultimately, I can say that wearing a barely there wrap top was pretty nice in a heat wave. However, I’m convinced celebs tape their shirts to their chests. There’s no way they can go all day without a wardrobe malfunction — I would know.

And despite a few of my own sartorial mishaps, and some unwanted male attention, I think I’m going to keep the shirt. Maybe I’ll find a more appropriate place to wear it — like the beach, or a poolside soirée.

Until then, I’m ordering some fashion tape, just in case.

Get the look:

To try the daring trend on the cheap, check out a $16.99 wrap top from Amazon:

Model wearing a wrap top from Amazon.com

Or this one, for $9.99 to $15.99, depending on color and size.

Model wearing a wrap top from Amazon.com

To DIY, here’s how to tie a scarf as a top:

Hold the silky scarf out horizontally behind you so it stretches across your back. Loop both sides in front of you, crossing in the center of your chest and covering your cleavage. Tie behind your neck and adjust the front as necessary. Fashion tape is recommended for coverage and security! (Hollywood Fashion Secrets makes great tape)

Satin scarves for sale at Amazon.com


Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.