Eagle plot hole debate of lord of the rings, settled for good

Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings trilogy contains one of the great mysteries of our modern era. This is a question asked among friends, on Reddit, on Quora, in Stack Exchange, and on the dearly departed Yahoo Answers. It has become immortalized in memes, video-essays, and even stop motion lego. It will never die.

Why did the fellowship not just ride the eagle to Mordor?

That is, if Gandalf can ask a kite to bring a giant hawk to save him from Saruman. the Fellowship of the Ring Or pick up Sam and Frodo from the lava fields of Mount Doom Return of the KingWhy, he couldn’t take a ring to Mordor to summon some giant chiles, shortening the Ring Quest for months?

This question bothers me. Nay, it tortures me. So I’m going to answer it, and prove once and for all that it’s not a fucking case why they didn’t just ride the Eagles for the Morders.

The giant eagle that Gandalf calls in. the Fellowship of the Ring Is sentimental, a whole race of giant eagles that are as old as dwarfs or ents. This is one of the many bits of Tolkien lore that Philip Boynes, Peter Jackson, and Fran Walsh decided would remain on the cutting floor of a trilogy that was already over nine hours long.

Gandalf’s special eagle friend is Gwahir the Windlord, who owns Gandalf for some time paid to the magician – possibly a life-loan, though Hobbit And The Lord of the Rings There are some contradictions on this. When Gwahir gave Gandalf a ride The Lord of the Rings, He is doing the magician a favor. He does not request.

Gwahir sees Gandalf from over Saruman’s tower and agrees to redeem him, but will only take him as Rohan’s adores. Next, he saw Gandalf above the summit of Zerk-Zigil, when he defeated Balrogh, and agreed to take him on another short trip to the Lothlorians. When Gandalf asked Gomahir to help save Sam and Frodo from Mount Doom, it was with a promise to never ask him for anything else again. “Twice you have given birth to me, Gwahir my friend, […] If you are willing, you will pay for all three times, ”he told Windlord Return of the king.

Like how Gandalf flexes power The Lord of the Rings, It is not about magic, but about politics. The giant Garuda of Middle-earth are not animals like Shadowfax; They have their own society and concerns. And like everyone else in the story, it takes a lot of work to take care of all these Dark Lord’s stuff until it directly affects them. The eagle cannot take the fellowship to Mordor because Gandalf cannot summon a squadron of birds on Mount Doom divebomb.

Without Bowens, Jackson, and Walsh’s throwing line or hung lampshades, it’s worth it for fans of the film to know why the Fellowship can’t ride the Eagles for Mordor. But the real problem is that fans of the book are always with answers.

Back in my world of Warcraft Day, I demonstrated that the best way to get useful suggestions from a free zone-wide chat was to ask your question about the location of that search NPC, and then ask a friend about something you know. Answer was not the correct answer. The first indifferent players leap and perform to “correct” your friend far superior

Knowledge of ashenvale forest or whatever.

This is the real reason why the eagle question will never die: it’s so delicious Lord of the Rings Fans. The Lord of the Rings The plot is not a hole. How dare you! Film viewers will keep asking, and book readers will keep answering, and we will never escape the “Eagles, Explained” cycle.

I myself was trapped in this trap for many years before I realized that the book explanation of the Eagle question is not the real answer.

Movie fans should be able to find out on their own

Perhaps Jackson’s Lord of the Rings trilogy did not adequately underline it, but all that the fellowship does on Ring Quest is to maintain the ignorance of Sauron’s existence. The moment the Dark Lord realizes that there are plans to destroy him instead of using the ring, he will turn his entire operation into Fraud Free for All. This is why Gandalf and Alronad gather a small group to sneak into Mordor Fellowship. This is why Gandalf and Aragorn actively mislead Sauron into thinking that the ring is in Minas Tirith Return of the king.

The eagle plan is cool, but it is not secret. The fellowship is huge, because the one-ring-sensing warrior cannot ride the eagle to Mordor due to the flying snake-dragon monsters riding through the half-mile-wide aura of kings and their fears. The moment the eagle swoops, the fellowship shows its hand, and if the plan fails, Sauron will recover the ring and immediately reunite with a power he hasn’t held in 6,000 years. If Ringbear dies in Moria, or is overlooked atop a mountain, or in a dead marsh, or is killed by orche kidnappers, the ring will be lost once again, to good forces. And evil.

The Eagle cannot take the fellowship to Mordor because it is a really shining plan.

But here’s the thing. She is Too Not the real answer.

Plot holes are not really about plots

When Buzz Lightwear freezes with other toys, when a human walks into a room, if he believes that he is in fact a space ranger? How is it possible for an Alien Powerbook 5300 to download a virus to an Alien Mothership? really As an astronaut it is hard to train as an offshore drillerThe Why didn’t Jack come to the door with Rose? Why doesn’t Batman just kill the Joker?

The possibility is that with at least one of the above examples, the idea of ​​a person seriously demanding that the film provide you with an answer. And chances are you Too Every time you watch it you have a movie or two, which leaves you with a mind-question. And I can hear you saying, “Okay, the things that bother me are Real plot holes. Those other things … people just need to relax and enjoy the film. “

The thing about plot holes is that they are not just about the film. They Mostly About the viewer. If you can’t stop thinking about logical inconsistencies, it could be because the film failed to engage you in believing that. But it’s just likely that you just … were not in it.

You might not be fond of science fiction, and these laser swords bore you, so you find yourself focused on how ships make sound in space, which is impossible. You might not be in a romantic drama, so you focus on yourself as to why no one in this film just talks about their feelings, which would really help Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy in this task.

Every story is Some even That some person One may consider logical inconsistency. But the stories are a contract between the teller and the listener. The listener will connect with the storyteller’s story, and the narrator will get to tell the story he has created. If you have to ask “why did the story not X,” when the story is clearly about “Y”, then you’re not engaged in it. And the answer is always the same: it remains a story. And they made it about Y.

The real answer to why the Eagle can’t just fly a Ring to Mordor is that the flight of Frodo and Sam to Mount Doom is a completely different story from their long, lonely struggle against impossible odds. You may also ask why Elderd and Gandalf did not raise forces to attack Mordor, and Then Throw the ring at Mount Doom. You may also ask why they did not take the power of the ring for themselves.

Tolkien invented the eagle Hobbit, And used them sparingly as a fast travel system for his magician The Lord of the Rings. Boynes, Jackson, and Walsh brought him to the big screen in the glory of all their wings. The chiles have an explanation, but they don’t really need it. The story of Lord of the Rings is the story of Tolkein, Boyce, Jackson, and Walsh wanted to tell. A story with Relevant Huge eagle.